Changing of the guard
Last week, The Guardsman opened in the West End. Next week
it will close. Here, its star Michael Pennington reveals what went wrong
Thursday
October 19, 2000
The Guardian
John Gielgud once said that you work harder at your
failures than your successes, and since any play is a great experiment, it's important
to look back and see what went wrong. His much-loved voice rings in my ears this
week.
The work itself is a private business, and nobody else is much interested in that. But the story behind The Guardsman's closure is already seeping out into the public domain and looks likely, unlike the show, to run and run. So: no witch-hunt, but some facts.
The producer of the play is Paddy Wilson. His temporary landlords at the Albery are the Ambassadors Theatre Group. The critical reception for the show has been poor, but not that poor - the Times was good, the Guardian too to some extent, and there have been good television reviews. The word-of-mouth is good, and advance bookings have built healthily since the first performance on October 4. Under normal circumstances, the show could have looked forward to an honourable two or three month run.
As it turns out, it never really had a chance. Before The Guardsman opened, plans appear to have been already advanced to bring The Mystery of Charles Dickens into the Albery early in November. During its last week on tour, The Guardsman company and staff were requested by Paddy Wilson to take a salary cut, which in the case of some of the principals amounted to 80% of their negotiated fees, although the advance was not bad for a new and unfamiliar play. The proposal was that the cast would return to their original salaries in week three of the London run, and be reimbursed what they had deferred for the first two weeks by the end of week six. The reality was that the sixth week was unlikely to be available to us; the third barely. Paddy Wilson assures me that he didn't know this.
The company eventually agreed to the deferment. In this event, all it has really achieved is to reduce Paddy Wilson's costs on the show's demise.
Without a rush on the box office, there seem to have been no refunds available to "nurse" the production through its critical first two weeks. Paddy Wilson attributes the problem to the loss of an investor halfway through the pre-London tour (a loss that Lady Bracknell might have described as "careless"); I am not convinced that the show's investment base was secure from the start. To me, there were signs of under-resource and false economies even then; and Equity, who require a deposit equivalent to two weeks' actors' salaries at the beginning of such a project, didn't get it until just before the West End opening.
The relationship between a producer and a theatre owner is a complicated one; Ambassadors Theatre Group had hesitations about the show's "legs" in any case. Suppose they had doubts about receiving their due rents from the producer as well, and you can well see that they might begin to make other arrangements for the Albery and to see the Guardsman as a brief "filler".
Still, a show which clearly had limited but still honourable expectations in the
West End has sunk almost without trace. As I write, some of those associated with
the production are still owed money, quite apart from the pay deferment. All are
embarrassed to be the last to hear what much of London seemed to know. Producers
are a hardy and courageous lot in a high-risk business, and theatre-owners need to
keep their lights on, but it can be difficult to judge how unlucky a producer has
to be before he is to blame. For a hard-working cast and staff, it can be difficult,
too, to detect the fault-lines beneath, let alone know what to do about them. For
both parties, as Gielgud said, failure can be fascinating. RIP.
Return to The Guardsman
Archives Jan/June 2012 |
Archives July/December 2011 |
Archives Jan/June 2011 |
Archives July/December 2010 |
Archives Jan/June 2010 |
Archives July/Dec 2009 |
Archives Jan/June 2009 |
Stage |
Audio |
Television |
Radio |
Film |
Books |
Plays |
Anton Chekhov |
Sweet William |
English Shakespeare Company |
Readings |
Direction |
An interview wiith Antony himself |
Reviews |
Michael Pennington on Ibsen |
Exeunt.com |
Ibsen's Judgement at The Print Room |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Interview |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Shakespearean actor learns from 'Love' |
Reviews |
Collaboration & Taking Sides |
San Francisco Sentinel |
The News |
Reviews Chichester |
Reviews London |
On ... Doing a West End Double |
When Bobby Met Terry |
Reviews |
Nellie Ternan |
Reviews |
A curious character |
Reviews |
The Short Answer |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The Knives Are Out |
Reviews |
They call it puppet love |
Reviews |
Interview |
A performance fit for a King |
A World of Schemers |
Reviews |
Peter's friends |
From Russia With Love |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Coping with the Apocalypse |
Pennington back in fold |
Labours of love |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Changing of the Guard |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Old Vic's Master of Disguise |
Studies in misogyny |
Reviews |
The Entertainer finds new life ... |
Reviews |
Ugly Americans, British Style |
In Defence of the Playwright |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The thing with this play |
There's something nice ... |
Reviews |
Reviews |
How to be in two plays at one time |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Rigorous romantic |
If this is Venice |
Reviews |
Bring on the Russian Horses |
Man with a lean and hungry look |
Reviews |
Reviews |
In the shadows .... |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
A state of mind and body |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The Travels of Michael |
First Wicket Down |
Reviews |
Way of the Actor |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Former Spear Carrier |
One man's week |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Limelight 1967 |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Chekhov's Vaudevilles |
The cherries on Chekhov's birthday cake |
A Jubilee |
Reviews |
Cottesloe 1984 |
Dublin 1990 |
Old Vic 1997 |
Winchester Festival 2003 |
ETT 2003 |
Hampstead Theatre 2008 |
Little Angel Theatre |
Arcola Theatre |
Guthrie Theater |
Hampstead Theatre London |
Chicago Shakespeare Theatre |
Oxford Playhouse |
Salisbury Playhouse |
Theatre Royal Northampton |
reviews |
Talks about book |
From Macbeth to Lear |
Performance |
Direction - Twelfth Night |
Books |
Videos |
Theatre company head quits |
The Henry Trilogy |
The Wars of the Roses |
Coriolanus |
The Winter's Tale |
Macbeth |
Henry IV Part I |
Henry IV Part II |
Henry V |
Reviews |
Articles |
Heady Challenge |
Hurray for the new Henry |
The Bard takes to the Road |
A bubble for the Bard |
Marathon Man |
Bard Boy |
Richard II |
Henry IV Part I |
Henry IV Part II |
Henry V |
Henry VI Lancaster |
Henry VI York |
Richard III |
Reviews |
Articles |
A Magnificent Seven |
Star Wars, Rose Wars |
An ambitious programme |
Tough company |
The Battle of the Bards |
Cycling Shakespeare |
Histories for our time |
A garment all of blood |
Coriolanus & WT Reviews |
Articles |
Roman Hero for our day |
Sun rises on Coriolanus |
A theatrical tour de force |
Son of Shakespeare-Wallah |
Bard on the Run |
Reviews |
Articles |
Now and thane |
Bard stripped bare |
Reviews |
The Story of the Wars of the Roses |
Operation Shakespeare |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
A Midsummer Night's Dream |
Twelfth Night (Chicago) |
Twelfth Night (Tokyo) |
Kafka - A Report to the Academy |
Alone Together |
Twelfth Night Across the Continents |
On Acting and Directing Shakespeare |
Reviews |
Reviews |
By Gloucester Docks |
The Name of the Rose |
Felix in the Underworld |
Antony and Cleopatra |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Classics for Pleasure |
Reviews |
Sentimental journey |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Lucky Stryk |
Reviews |
From Russia ... with love |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The book the Bishop burnt |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The Return of Sherlock Holmes |
Fragile |
Britain isn't Working |
The Iron Lady |
Elementary, my dear Miss Watson |
Review |
Hamlet. A User's Guide |
Twelfth Night. A User's Guide |
Are You There Crocodile? |
A Pocket Guide |
A Midsummer Night's Dream. A User's Guide |
Players of Shakespeare |
Audio |
Books |
Direction |
English Shakespeare Company |
Film |
Theatre |
Radio |
Readings |
Television |