Portrait of a Planet
The Sunday Times, 4th February 1973, Harold Hobson
There is too much emotion in ‘Small Craft Warnings’; and too little in Friedrich Dürrenmatt’s ‘Portrait of A Planet’ (Prospect Theatre Company’s workshop production: Arts Theatre, Cambridge). This play is a series of arid deductions drawn from a fallacious premise. It begins, and also ends, with four gods, one of them deaf (everything has to be repeated to him), contemplating from a great distance the explosion of a sun. “The cosmological hypothesis which,” says Mr Dürrenmatt, “was the source of ‘Portrait of a Planet’ [is that] planets only come into existence when the disintegrated matter from exploding suns … collects around clouds of hydrogen which are themselves in the process of forming suns, so that we are in fact living upon the remains of an unimaginable cosmic catastrophe.” Since, according to Mr Dürrenmatt, life begins with a catastrophe, he concludes that everything in it must be catastrophic.
The play, such as it is, and as it goes on, is a series of disasters: the abolition of cannibalism leads to starvation, a man and a woman die on the moon whilst reciting speeches from ‘Romeo and Juliet,’ the President of the United States gets into a panic, and America and Russia co-operate to ensure that the war in Vietnam is not brought to an end. All this is shown to us drily and without feeling, as if it were an irrefutable intellectual argument.
It is nothing of the sort. A cosmic explosion is not in itself a catastrophe. There is no reason to suppose that matter is any less happy when exploding than when in a steady state. It all depends on the effect of the explosion: an explosion that makes human life possible is quite different, in emotional terms from one that destroys it. It is no more true to say that because human life began with an explosion therefore everything in it must be disastrous, than it would be to argue that because a car cannot start without an explosion every drive must end in a smash. The dullness of Mr Dürrenmatt’s exposition ceases to bore only when the shabby colloquialism of James Kirkup’s translation makes it infuriating. The sole consolation is in some of the performances: Linda Marlowe, Ron Smerczak, and Michael Pennington especially play with grace, commitment and authority.
Stage and Television Today, 8th February 1973
The Prospect Theatre Company are to be congratulated on their policy of “workshop presentations” outside the larger theatres. The latest is Durrenmatt’s ‘Portrait of a Planet’ at the Arts, Cambridge, in James Kirkup’s translation under the direction of Kenny McBain.
Durrenmatt’s central intention are obscure, and treatment is episodic, grimly humorous, and in places savage. The play begins and ends with the same scene: four bored gods, not really interested in the fate of the earth and its inhabitants. In between, successive cameos treat of Vietnam, peace negotiations, racial intolerance, ecological crises, power politics, the beginnings and endings of civilisation, lunar adventures and so on.
The scene involving two astronauts, a man and a woman, being monitored as their oxygen gives out is typical of Durrenmatt’s approach. The monitors are sadly but transiently involved in the tragedy as the man quotes “Romeo and Juliet” but, as his dying sentence reverts to patriotism, they (the monitors) change from essentially human beings to mere enthusiastic functionaries of the system. The impact of this and other scenes if evocative, cumulative and perturbing, but that is legitimate theatre and no bad thing.
Durrenmatt’s format make terrific demands on the protean talents of the cast, each member taking at least a dozen parts, all with verisimilitude and conviction, (and a clarity of diction which lifted the words off the page and vitalised the script).
Return to Portrait of a Planet
Archives Jan/June 2012 |
Archives July/December 2011 |
Archives Jan/June 2011 |
Archives July/December 2010 |
Archives Jan/June 2010 |
Archives July/Dec 2009 |
Archives Jan/June 2009 |
Stage |
Audio |
Television |
Radio |
Film |
Books |
Plays |
Anton Chekhov |
Sweet William |
English Shakespeare Company |
Readings |
Direction |
An interview wiith Antony himself |
Reviews |
Michael Pennington on Ibsen |
Exeunt.com |
Ibsen's Judgement at The Print Room |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Interview |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Shakespearean actor learns from 'Love' |
Reviews |
Collaboration & Taking Sides |
San Francisco Sentinel |
The News |
Reviews Chichester |
Reviews London |
On ... Doing a West End Double |
When Bobby Met Terry |
Reviews |
Nellie Ternan |
Reviews |
A curious character |
Reviews |
The Short Answer |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The Knives Are Out |
Reviews |
They call it puppet love |
Reviews |
Interview |
A performance fit for a King |
A World of Schemers |
Reviews |
Peter's friends |
From Russia With Love |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Coping with the Apocalypse |
Pennington back in fold |
Labours of love |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Changing of the Guard |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Old Vic's Master of Disguise |
Studies in misogyny |
Reviews |
The Entertainer finds new life ... |
Reviews |
Ugly Americans, British Style |
In Defence of the Playwright |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The thing with this play |
There's something nice ... |
Reviews |
Reviews |
How to be in two plays at one time |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Rigorous romantic |
If this is Venice |
Reviews |
Bring on the Russian Horses |
Man with a lean and hungry look |
Reviews |
Reviews |
In the shadows .... |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
A state of mind and body |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The Travels of Michael |
First Wicket Down |
Reviews |
Way of the Actor |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Former Spear Carrier |
One man's week |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Limelight 1967 |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Chekhov's Vaudevilles |
The cherries on Chekhov's birthday cake |
A Jubilee |
Reviews |
Cottesloe 1984 |
Dublin 1990 |
Old Vic 1997 |
Winchester Festival 2003 |
ETT 2003 |
Hampstead Theatre 2008 |
Little Angel Theatre |
Arcola Theatre |
Guthrie Theater |
Hampstead Theatre London |
Chicago Shakespeare Theatre |
Oxford Playhouse |
Salisbury Playhouse |
Theatre Royal Northampton |
reviews |
Talks about book |
From Macbeth to Lear |
Performance |
Direction - Twelfth Night |
Books |
Videos |
Theatre company head quits |
The Henry Trilogy |
The Wars of the Roses |
Coriolanus |
The Winter's Tale |
Macbeth |
Henry IV Part I |
Henry IV Part II |
Henry V |
Reviews |
Articles |
Heady Challenge |
Hurray for the new Henry |
The Bard takes to the Road |
A bubble for the Bard |
Marathon Man |
Bard Boy |
Richard II |
Henry IV Part I |
Henry IV Part II |
Henry V |
Henry VI Lancaster |
Henry VI York |
Richard III |
Reviews |
Articles |
A Magnificent Seven |
Star Wars, Rose Wars |
An ambitious programme |
Tough company |
The Battle of the Bards |
Cycling Shakespeare |
Histories for our time |
A garment all of blood |
Coriolanus & WT Reviews |
Articles |
Roman Hero for our day |
Sun rises on Coriolanus |
A theatrical tour de force |
Son of Shakespeare-Wallah |
Bard on the Run |
Reviews |
Articles |
Now and thane |
Bard stripped bare |
Reviews |
The Story of the Wars of the Roses |
Operation Shakespeare |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
A Midsummer Night's Dream |
Twelfth Night (Chicago) |
Twelfth Night (Tokyo) |
Kafka - A Report to the Academy |
Alone Together |
Twelfth Night Across the Continents |
On Acting and Directing Shakespeare |
Reviews |
Reviews |
By Gloucester Docks |
The Name of the Rose |
Felix in the Underworld |
Antony and Cleopatra |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Classics for Pleasure |
Reviews |
Sentimental journey |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Lucky Stryk |
Reviews |
From Russia ... with love |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The book the Bishop burnt |
Reviews |
Reviews |
The Return of Sherlock Holmes |
Fragile |
Britain isn't Working |
The Iron Lady |
Elementary, my dear Miss Watson |
Review |
Hamlet. A User's Guide |
Twelfth Night. A User's Guide |
Are You There Crocodile? |
A Pocket Guide |
A Midsummer Night's Dream. A User's Guide |
Players of Shakespeare |
Audio |
Books |
Direction |
English Shakespeare Company |
Film |
Theatre |
Radio |
Readings |
Television |